2012/08/23

Up Until Now I've Been Polite

Don't say another Goddamn word. Up until now, I've been polite. If you say anything else—word one—I will kill myself. And when my tainted spirit finds its destination, I will topple the master of that dark place. From my black throne, I will lash together a machine of bone and blood, and fueled by my hatred for you this fear engine will bore a hole between this world and that one. When it begins, you will hear the sound of children screaming - as though from a great distance. A smoking orb of nothing will grow above your bed, and from it will emerge a thousand starving crows. As I slip through the widening maw in my new form, you will catch only a glimpse of my radiance before you are incinerated. Then, as tears of bubbling pitch stream down my face, my dark work will begin. I will open one of my six mouths, and I will sing the song that ends the Earth.
Tycho Brahe, on the subject of Warhammer being a ripoff of Warcraft
Reality check rant-fest.
  • You know those people who think that we'd totally have free energy or cars that run on water, except the big evil companies are totally keeping the technology a secret?

    Well they are people who didn't understand that the Candlemakers' petition is a satire on protectionism, by Bastiat. The whole point of the device there employed, the reductio ad absurdum, is that nobody would actually do such things—yet the opinions the target of the satire have expressed would seem to lead to that.
  • On a similar "doesn't know rhetoric from logic" front—a symptom of psychosis, you know—the next time someone, debating me, treats obvious rhetorical wordplay as if it were actually the agreed-upon definition of the word, I can't be held accountable for my actions.

    For instance, a half-educated unserious dilletante, who knows no more social science than the beasts of the field and is also suspiciously similar to a Men's Rights weenie, thinks he can cite Twilight, in a discussion over whether women consume more porn than men. Based on a Jonah Goldberg column. Which, aside from the fact I doubt even Goldberg really meant that literally, Goldberg is not the language-Pope.

    And the Superversive guy, who thinks, on the basis of another opinion column, that all literature that can be shown to be in any way influenced by another work, including spinoffs, new treatments of legendary material, or new installments in franchises, is fanfiction. Yes, that's right, he can't see a difference between Deep Space Nine and a KirkXSpock lemon.

    Do you want me to actually analyze the corpus of English for you? That's how linguists decide what a word's definition is. It's the way that dictionaries get written. And I will bet your life—penny-ante wager though that is—that actual usage bears out my definition, not yours.

    Hell, while we're at it? If we just redefine things like "holy sites" and "authority to define Christian doctrine" as "economic resources", the Marxist theory of human conflict becomes 100% correct. That's no less scurrilous than these guys' approach to words.
  • On an actually lighter note, no work—unless authored on a typewriter with a doppelsigrune key—is more blatantly bigot-propaganda than the Song of Ice and Fire books, or the Assassin's Creed games.

    No, not even Birth of a Nation; that actually has a closer relation to the historical events it purports to involve than those things do. It is a more accurate portrayal of Reconstruction than A Waste of Ink and Paper is of the Middle Ages, or than Assassin Screed is of anything that ever happened, ever.

3 comments:

penny farthing said...

I was hurled into a swirling maelstrom of horror and despair just the other day when a guy told me I should play Assassin's Creed because I'm really into history. Unless maybe he doesn't like history nerds and likes to hurt them?

It's a similar feeling to when people see my Tesla tattoo and launch into a speech on how the government covered up all his research and JP Morgan (or the government?) had him silenced because he was going to give the world free energy. Dude thought Einstein was black magic crazy science. He wasn't gonna be OK with violating the laws of thermodynamics.

Nicholas D.C. Wansbutter said...

Okay, so A Song of Rape and Torture is clearly misogynistic and anti-Catholic bigotry. But I'm guessing you've picked up a few more themes?

By the way, a friend insisted that I must watch the HBO series so just to humour him I borrowed the first season from the library. I thought maybe it wouldn't be as dark since it's on TV, then was violently reminded this is HBO as I started watching it. If possible, the TV series is even more dark, depairing, depraved, and anti-medieval/Catholic nonsense than the books. Although Peter Dunklage is admittedly very good as Tyrion Lannister who was one of the few barely tolerable characters from the books.

Sophia's Favorite said...

Those two themes are plenty, but what about the David Brin-style Socialist Realism? I mean how Martin's portrayal of non-"democratic" systems is the sort of vilifying propaganda generally associated with totalitarian regimes. I didn't find it that surprising—liberal ideology is still an ideology, and all ideologues will pull the same tricks given half an excuse—but I was a little surprised that an allegedly literate public let him get away with it.

Just for example, Martin's nobles are, each individually, and with only a few (doomed) exceptions, worse than Giles de Rais or Elizabeth Bathory, whose bad behavior certainly seems to have excited comment in their societies—but in Martin's? No, that's just how all nobles are. Of course, all the historical aristocrats Martin could claim as a basis for his portrayal were excommunicated and/or jailed and/or executed; the only person who got away with as many personal or hired killings as the typical noble of his setting, is someone Martin shares at least 75% of his political opinions with—Che "personally shot more than 300 farm-boys" Guevara.